In Endicott's 2-0 week (1-0 CNE), O'Toole was once again a standout in net. Over the two game span, the freshman goalkeeper racked up seven saves and picked up another two shutout wins.
On Tuesday, October 1 at MIT, O'Toole held the Engineers scoreless with a five-save effort, a few times sprawling out to make potential game-saving plays in the 1-0 victory. The impressive performance earned him his third individual win of the season.
A few days later on Saturday, he repeated his excellence in the Blue and Green's third conference win of the season and third consecutive shutout victory via a 2-0 win over Wentworth. The two-save shutout effort from O'Toole handed the Gulls sole possession of first place in the CNE standings (6-4-1, 3-0-0 CNE).